McLain Ward standing atop the leaderboard on the final night of the Royal Agricultural Winter Fair is familiar territory. He’s won the Grand Prix ten times over three decades at the 104-year-old Toronto legacy event. But it’s not the victories he keeps track of—it’s the times he missed the mark.

“I think about the times I was second and third,” he admitted. “There were a few.”

And his memory for those losses is long. Asked which one still stings the most, he didn’t hesitate:

“I was third on Orchestre,” he said. “It was one of my first really good horses, and he had jumped double clean in every Nations Cup. Back then, [the Royal] was nine days. On the Sunday [there was] a big lunch, you had to wear your suit and then change in the bathroom and jump the Nations Cup—it just shows you how things have changed. But I remember that [loss]. Still bugs me a little bit.”

He’s had more than a minute to get over it, too. That third-place finish? It was in the mid-90s.

This year, there will be no lingering sense of disappointment to haunt Ward as he leaves Toronto. On Saturday, the world No. 5 topped the Longines FEI Jumping World Cup Toronto on Jordan Molga M to claim his 10th grand prix victory at The Royal and fifth World Cup title in Toronto.

“Jordan has been coming into great form,” Ward said. “He’s been 100% on his game all fall.”

Four pairs advanced to the jump-off in the Bernardo Costa Cabral-designed course. Ward and “Jordan” crossed the timers in 36.34 seconds, ahead of Aaron Vale (USA) and Helios du Moulin (37.68 seconds) and Jad Dana (LEB) and Itchcock de Dames (4/36.74s).

“My horse has a big stride, and I tried to use that stride to my advantage,” he continued. “I think I made up the time in the beginning and then was able to keep it together coming home.”

Ward took over the reins on the 12-year-old KWPN gelding (Etoulon VDL x HGT Dulf van den Bisschop) last fall. The pair found early success in Florida this winter, then were sidelined for four months in the spring following a bout of colic. He’s back now, and Ward says, better than ever.

“[Jordan] has actually come back stronger,” Ward said. “This horse has proven to handle indoors well, and if he feels in form, we’ll definitely aim toward [the Finals].”

You can bank on him aiming to defend the title in Toronto next year, too.

“It’s special to win, always. I’m competitive. I love to win. I love to win in the places that mean something to me. This place means something to me. My father came here for years. I came here as a teenager with people that I really admired and were mentors. And now I’m bringing the next generation here with me and making the sport here the best it can be.”

With three legs remaining in the FEI World Cup Jumping North American League, Ward now tops the standings on 44 points, ahead of Daniel Coyle (34) and Shange Sweetnam. The NAL next stops in Los Angeles, USA, Nov 10-14.