Turning for home with a 1-1/2 length lead and a head full of steam in last year’s Breeders’ Cup Classic, it seemed like a mere formality that California Chrome would add another illustrious chapter to his storied career. This is how these things are supposed to play out anyway, right? The California bred on his home dirt, around the world and back again, pouring it on for his legions of fans that packed into Santa Anita to witness their King’s coronation. It was all playing out perfectly…

Until Arrogate showed up.

The imposing roan colt came charging on the outside, gobbling up ground with his pulverizing stride, closing in on his target like a marathoner who’d hailed a cab to the finish line. Two heavyweights trading wallops until the final bell.

If every story needs a hero, then there must be a villain, and on paper, Arrogate seemed to check all the boxes. Where California Chrome is the “People’s Horse”, Arrogate entered the Classic as more mystery than merit. Making just his 6th career start, his first in over two months and his first against older horses, there was reason to question the readiness of . Where California Chrome was bred for the price of a used Hyundai and trained by a universally liked hardscrabble lifer, Arrogate was simply another perfectly assembled luxury liner in the garage of racing royalty.

Fortunately, it doesn’t work like that in this sport. Sure, there was a collective letdown in the grandstand that evening, but it quickly shifted into mass appreciation for this pair of rivals who gave it everything they had, came home safe and put on one hell of a show.

Groom Eduardo Luna offers some refreshment for his star Arrogate after his Breeders’ Cup Classic victory.

And now we get to do it all over again this Saturday in the inaugural $12,000,000 Pegasus World Cup at Gulfstream Park.

It will be the first start for each since their Breeders’ Cup duel, over a track neither have competed on. Both horses picked up prestigious hardware in the meantime—California Chrome took home the 2016 Horse of the Year Award, while Arrogate was named the 2016 Longines World’s Best Racehorse.