Chestnut gelding by McGee, out of Fair Empress, bred in Kentucky by F.D. “Dixie” Knight
Nicknames: Old Bones, The Galloping Hatrack
Record: 99 starts, 50 wins, 17 places, 17 shows
Career earnings: $252,996
Major wins: Clark Handicap, Brooklyn Handicap, Philadelphia Handicap, Autumn Gold Cup, Kentucky Derby
1922 Horse of the Year
Kentucky hard boot Cal Milam was hardly impressed by the gangly yearling when he spotted him at the 1916 Yearling Sale at Saratoga, but for $1,500, wound up bringing him home. Hoping his youngster would eventually kill off the competition, he named him Exterminator.
A couple weeks before the 1918 Kentucky Derby, Milam sold Exterminator to businessman Willis Sharp Kilmer for $9,000, who was really just looking for a decent training partner for his stable star and Juvenile champion Sun Briar.
While the public affectionately knew Exterminator as “Old Bones” or “The Galloping Hatrack”, Kilmer originally dismissed him as simply “The Goat”, and was reluctant to have him race in his colors. It was only after Kilmer was forced to scratch Sun Briar from the 1918 Kentucky Derby that Churchill Downs President Matt Winn convinced him to enter the gelding in the Derby. Exterminator won easily at odds of 30-1.
In a career that spanned an astounding eight years and 99 races, Exterminator hauled over six metric tons of combined weight—12,580 1/2 pounds, to be exact. He won a record 35 stakes races and was named Champion Handicap Horse three years in a row, in addition to being Horse of the Year in 1922.
“(He was) the greatest all-around Thoroughbred in American racing history.”
– Colonel Matt J. Winn
Retired at 9, Kilmer brought him home to his Court Manor Estate in Virginia. Old Bones passed away in 1945 at the age of 30, and is buried right next to old rival and stablemate, Sun Briar.
“He lived the life of a country gentleman among green pastures and shady trees. When he seemed a bit lonely, a shaggy little pony named Peanuts was brought to join him. They became inseparable companions. After some time the pony died and Exterminator was so unhappy that another pony as nearly like the first as possible was hurriedly procured. Exterminator examined the substitute, and soon accepted him; in a short time he and Peanuts II were great pals. Sometimes when Exterminator was grazing quietly, his head would come up – possibly a distant auto horn recalled the sound of a bugle – and he would tear around the paddock, little Peanuts trying frantically to keep up”
– C. W. Anderson
Exterminator’s popularity is further evidenced in this note from Ernest Hemingway to his publisher, Charles Scribner, sent sometime in the 1920’s:
Again, 10% will not do.
Again, Bet on Exterminator.
Best and Fondest,
Check out more of racing’s legendary and forgotten stories at the Horse Racing History facebook page.